Sorry for the delay Lefty, Im still getting my way through all of the threads and topics.
Ok, Deadeye Darts:
Price: definitely a +1. One of the cheapest online shops here in Australia.
Selection: again a +1 here. Very big selection.
Website: +1, easy to navigate, all categories listed down the left side of page.
S&H: +1, padded post bags used. Depending on what time of day I order will mean next day delivery, otherwise 2 days tops in Australia.
Postage: +1. $13 for delivery in Australia. It can be expensive if you dont buy a lot in one go.
Customer Service: I will give +1 here as I have never had a need to use it because of their excellent S&H.
Comments: They have good specials from time to time. Like quality flights cheap if you buy 10 sets. Most items get discounted if you buy more than 5 at a time.